Three of my ads were removed on the same day for allegedly not complying with the policy on hateful content. I’d like to appeal all three together, as I believe they were flagged in error:
Ad ID #1740185591 — “German Sword - WW2”
Ad ID #1740185661 — “German Dagger WW2”
Ad ID #1740185728 — “German Dagger WW2”
All three are genuine historical/vintage militaria collectibles, listed purely for their historical and collector value — not to promote or support any ideology, group, or form of hatred, violence, or intolerance. Before posting, I deliberately covered and obscured any markings or symbols that could be seen as promoting aggression, specifically so the listings would comply with your prohibited-content policy.
Could someone from the team please clarify:
The specific reason these ads were flagged, and which part of the content triggered the removal?
Whether historical WW2 militaria (swords, daggers) can be listed at all if such symbols are fully removed/covered, and if so, what conditions I need to meet?
If there’s anything I need to adjust to bring the listings into compliance, I’m happy to edit and repost. I’m glad to provide account details privately if needed for the review.
As part of our ongoing review and enforcement of prohibited items policies, we are strengthening our approach regarding offensive and obscene material, including Nazi-related artifacts and collectibles.*
This includes, but is not limited to, items such as stamps, letters, envelopes bearing Nazi symbols or references, currency issued under the Nazi regime, military documents, uniforms, military equipment, and any other items classified as Nazi memorabilia.
In alignment with Adevinta’s Global Ethical Standards and Human Rights principles, we have decided to remove listings that users report as inappropriate, offensive, or in violation of these policies.
We ask all users to respect this decision and refrain from posting World War II items that depict related symbols, and imagery.
Thank you for your understanding, cooperation, and continued support in helping maintain a respectful and safe marketplace for everyone.
Thank you for the detailed explanation - I understand this is a policy decision and I will comply. I have no intention of reposting anything that violates it.
I’d appreciate clarification on a few points, so I can stay fully within the rules going forward:
Scope: does this apply to all WW2-era militaria, or specifically to items bearing Nazi symbols/imagery? Your message lists a broad category of “Nazi memorabilia,” but the closing line refers to items “that depict related symbols and imagery.” For example — are Allied WW2 items, or German military items with no Nazi symbolism whatsoever (plain bayonets, helmets, edged weapons without insignia), also prohibited? I collect and sell historical militaria generally, so knowing the exact boundary matters to me.
Process: your message notes that listings are removed when users report them. In my case, all symbols were deliberately covered before posting, so the listings themselves did not display any prohibited imagery. Does a user report alone trigger removal, or is each reported listing reviewed against the policy first? I ask because a compliant listing could otherwise be removed simply because someone reported it.
Consistency: are these rules being applied across the platform going forward, or only to reported listings? I’d like to understand the standard so I know what is and isn’t acceptable to post.
Again, I’m not disputing your right to set the policy -I just want clear criteria so I don’t unintentionally break the rules again and risk my account. Thanks for your time.
Thank you for the great question and for your commitment to keeping our community safe and compliant. We truly appreciate your cooperation and are happy to clarify how our Offensive and Obscene Material policy applies to historical militaria.
1. Scope of the Policy Our policy strictly prohibits all Nazi-related artifacts and collectibles that promote supremacy, oppression, or the glorification of the former Fascist regime. This boundary applies specifically to items linked to the Nazi regime, rather than serving as a blanket ban on all World War II historical items.
Prohibited: Any items originating from, issued by, or manufactured for the Nazi regime (including currency, stamps, uniforms, letters, military script, or equipment) that depict Nazi symbols, as well as materials issued under Nazi occupation in invaded countries. This also includes any informational or graphic material promoting the supremacy of the regime, material depicting the suffering of persecuted nationalities, objects of torture, and any articles written to glorify the regime.
Allowed: Allied WWII militaria and general historical military items (such as plain helmets, uniforms, books, and letters) are permitted, provided they carry absolutely no Nazi insignia, references, or direct ties to the regime.