Additional Tips to Spot a Backyard Breeder

Getting Started Kijiji Policies Pet Rules & Policies
1

2. How to Spot a Puppy Mill or Backyard Breeder

These people actually have dogs, but they are running a cruel, high-volume commercial business out of hidden barns, basements, or dirty cages.

When dealing with a live seller, look out for these massive red flags:

  • The Parking Lot Meetup: If the seller refuses to let you come to their home and instead says, “I can meet you half-way in a Tim Hortons or Walmart parking lot to make it easier for you,” do not do it. They do this so you cannot see the terrible conditions the mother and puppies are living in.

  • The Mother is “Unavailable”: An ethical breeder will always insist that you meet the mother dog. If the seller makes an excuse (e.g., “The mom is at my sister’s house” or “She gets too aggressive around strangers”), they are likely hiding the fact that the mother is sick, over-bred, or not even there.

  • They Always Have Puppies: Ethical breeders only have 1 to 2 litters a year and usually have a waiting list before the dogs are even born. If a Kijiji seller constantly has multiple litters of different breeds available year-round, they are running a high-volume mill.

  • No Genetic Health Testing: Saying a puppy “went to the vet for a checkup” is not the same as genetic health testing. Reputable breeders screen the parents for breed-specific genetic defects (like hip dysplasia or heart issues) and will proudly show you official paperwork from organizations like the OFA (Orthopedic Foundation for Animals).

3. The Ultimate Verification Checklist

Before you hand over a single dollar for a dog on Kijiji, run through these safety checks:

The Registration Rule: In Canada, under the federal Animal Pedigree Act, it is illegal to sell a dog as “purebred” or “registered” unless it is officially registered with the Canadian Kennel Club (CKC). If a seller tells you, “The puppy is purebred, but it costs $500 extra if you want the papers,” they are breaking federal law.

  1. Insist on a Video Call: Before driving out, ask for a live FaceTime or WhatsApp video call. Ask them to show you the puppy playing in real-time alongside its mother. A scammer will immediately make an excuse and hang up.

  2. Ask Searching Questions: Ask why they chose to breed these two specific dogs, what socialization the puppies have had, and what food they are eating. Ethical breeders are obsessed with their dogs and will talk your ear off; puppy millers just want to talk about the price.

  3. Look for a Spay/Neuter Contract: Reputable breeders care immensely about where their dogs go. They will make you sign a legal contract stating you must have the dog fixed by a certain age and that if you can no longer care for the dog, you must return it to them. A puppy mill seller will hand over a dog with zero questions asked, as long as your cash clears.

Also, important to review:

1. How Many Breeds Do They Have?

  • Ethical Breeder: They stick to one or at most two distinct breeds. They are deeply knowledgeable about that specific type of dog, its temperament, genetic history, and unique lifestyle needs.

  • Puppy Mill: They frequently offer multiple different breeds or “designer” mixes at the same time. If their Kijiji profile has active ads for French Bulldogs, Poodles, and Golden Retrievers all at once, they are treating dogs like a high-volume factory line.

2. Litter Frequency & Waitlists

  • Ethical Breeder: They rarely breed their female dogs more than once a year. Because of this, they usually have a strict waiting list established before the puppies are even born.

  • Puppy Mill: They almost always have puppies available year-round. They will breed a female dog consecutively on every single heat cycle without giving her a break to maximize profits.

3. Visiting the Premises & Meeting the Parents

  • Ethical Breeder: They insist that you come to their home or facility. They will proudly show you the clean, humane environment where the puppies live and play, and they will always make sure you meet the mother dog.

  • Puppy Mill: They will do anything to keep you from seeing their facility. They will offer to ship the puppy or suggest meeting in a parking lot, on the side of the road, or at a nearby coffee shop “for your convenience.” If they bring up the mother, they will claim she is “at a partner’s farm” or “too aggressive around strangers.”

4. Screening & Vetting the Buyer

  • Ethical Breeder: They are incredibly choosy about where their puppies go. They will grill you with questions about your work schedule, your living space, your experience with dogs, and your lifestyle to make sure the match is perfect.

  • Puppy Mill: They ask zero questions about you. They don’t care about your living environment or if you know how to handle a dog—as long as your cash or e-transfer clears, the puppy is yours.

5. Medical History vs. Genetic Testing

  • Ethical Breeder: They invest heavily in official breed-specific genetic testing (such as OFA certifications for hips, eyes, and hearts) to ensure the parents aren’t passing down painful, expensive hereditary diseases.

  • Puppy Mill: They confuse basic veterinary care with genetic screening. They will give you a handwritten note saying the puppy “went to the vet for a checkup and deworming,” but they have no scientific health data regarding the parents.

6. Contracts and Lifetime Accountability

  • Ethical Breeder: They make you sign a detailed legal contract featuring a mandatory spay/neuter clause. Crucially, they will state that if your life changes and you can no longer care for the pet at any point in its life, you must return the dog to them.

  • Puppy Mill: They provide no contract or safety net. Once the transaction is finished, you are entirely on your own, and they will rarely reply to your messages if the dog develops severe medical or behavioral issues later.